What legal issues can you “spot” in this problem? How would you describe those issues in your own words?
What is a Nuisance?
Unreasonable and substantial interference with another person’s reasonable use and enjoyment of their land.
Nuisance in Tort & Property
What have you learned about the law of nuisance so far in your Torts class? How is nuisance relevant to property law?
Nuisance and Industrialization
What common problem is the court confronting in the cases you read this week: St. Helen’s Smelting, Shelfer v City of London Electrical Co, Canadian Paper Co., and Canadian Copper Co.?
Problem of Social Cost
In Sturges v Bridgman, do you agree with the court that the defendant has caused an injury to the plaintiff?
Why not say that the plaintiff has caused an injury to the defendant by building their consulting room in such an impractical spot?
Problem of Social Cost
Canadian courts in the late 19th and early 20th century began to address the problem of social cost from two angles:
What constitutes an “unreasonable” interference with plaintiff’s property in the local context of industrial activity?
What is the appropriate remedy for nuisance produced by industry?
Sturges v Bridgman
Two principles:
Coming to the nuisance
Character of the neighbourhood
St. Helen’s Smelting Co v Tipping
In what way does the court in St. Helen’s adapt the “character of the neighbourhood” analysis expressed in Sturges? Does this approach respond to the problem of social cost?
Remedies in Nuisance
Traditional remedy in nuisance is a permanent injunction (“right to exclude”)
Courts begin to recognize circumstances in which damages are appropriate but struggle to develop a legal framework to make this choice consistently
Shelfer v City of London Electrical Lighting Co.
“In my opinion, it may be stated as a good working rule that (1) If the injury to the plaintiff’s legal rights is small, (2) and is one which is capable of being estimated in money, (3) and is one which can be adequately compensated by a small money payment, (4) and the case is one in which it would be oppressive to the defendant to grant an injunction, then damages in substitution for an injunction may be given.”
Nuisance Remedies in the Canadian Courts
Do the judges in Canadian Copper Co. and in Canadian Paper Co. apply the Shelfer test? If not, what criteria do they apply?
Why do these judges reach different conclusions on the issue of remedy?
“Expropriation” in Nuisance Claims
“[An award of damages] is not, as was suggested in argument, equivalent to subjecting the plaintiff to a process of expropriation, it is merely applying the limitations and restrictions which the law imposes in relation to the pursuit of this particular form of remedy in order to prevent it becoming an instrument of injustice and oppression.” (Duff J, Canada Paper)
“Nor is it possible to maintain that damages will afford an adequate remedy to the plaintiff. If he were confined to this method of redress he would, in effect, be forced to submit to partial expropriation of his property … without statutory authority for such an exercise of eminent domain.” (Anglin J, Canada Paper)